Talk:World 3/@comment-3502824-20150201072859/@comment-25832576-20150204035054

^ By that logic, 1CL 5DD gets wrecked often at the first node if RNG is a bitch.

See what I did there? Both options suck if RNG is a bitch, its just a matter of whether you want the compass to suck, or battles to suck. Having used this composition for months I can say when it comes to combat it is far better than 1CL 5DD due to Tone/Chikuma's firepower, and seaplanes allowing both CAV and CL to double attack via artillery spotting (outside of the Nu node), while still going the right way most of the time. Yet that doesn't mean I think its better than 1CL 5DD.

Each has its own advantage and disadvantage, it's simply a matter of preference. Just because you prefer stable routing than more power doesn't mean others do, and it certainly doesn't give you the right to slam on this composition.