Talk:Exercises (PvP)/@comment-108.221.20.89-20141017040849/@comment-138.229.29.71-20141017043009

If you really sank 4/6 ships you get A automatically, so the opponent's ships really stayed at 1hp and need one more non-scratch hit to be considered sunk. Getting them red is never enough unless your own fleet suffer scratch damage at most since you need about 2.5x more damage dealth to get a B rating without sinking enough vessels.