Talk:Suggestion/@comment-1820055-20150207235023/@comment-25534439-20150211040827

"Should one have priority?"

Very much so. This is, ultimately, a wiki centered on the game. What matters is how the game treats her, which is clearly not as a CL.

We have a couple of these conflicts of classification outstanding currently: that of the CLTs squatting on the CL page, and also that of the Chitose/Chiyoda AV/CVL shift, where they're currently sitting on both the CVL list and their own Seaplane Tender list. These two differences were brought about by ships that change categories with remodelling and are mostly there for completeness and/or remodel comparisons. I'm of the opinion that these should be resolved, but that's another discussion.

Unlike those cases, Katori does not change class; She remains a Training Cruiser, and is clearly not treated as a CL in the game code. While she may have been a light cruiser serving training duties in reality, the historical interest should not be used in a method which will cause confusion. If a ship is listed on the CL page, it should be able to fill the role of a CL for fleet composition requirements. Unremodelled Kiso, Ooi, and Kitakami belong on the page because they can be used as CLs. As Katori cannot fill that role, she should not be on the CL page.

She belongs on the Auxilliary page.

(and the CLTs belong on their own page)