Talk:Intrepid/@comment-26148655-20180223141302/@comment-32869046-20180223165421

I have yet to see someone debunk ANY of the arguments presented here as to why Shibafu IS a good artist, other than the "he is shit" type of argument. We have stabilished the following already: - Throughout his works, he excels at proportions and volume control, trademarks for good artists, and quite honestly, he is the best at it among the artists of KC; - He HAS improved over the years, the fact that it is not as glaringly visible as the evolution of other artists is due to him already being a good artist in first place, and not changing his style. The other artists made far more mistakes than Shibafu ever did, and never once got this amount of flame; - Intrepid IS proportional, and has a design that takes into account historical accuracy and practicity, considering kanmusus are going into battle (High heels aren't exactly the kind of shoewear someone would like to use for any kind of physical activity); - The fix Shibafu made for Intrepid's face actually made a hell of a difference, and solved much of the problems that made her face feel like something was off;

It is ok not to like a piece of art. To derate an artist for his work without any consistent or relevant argument that is not based on subjectivity and attacks ad hominem, is just outright wrong and just exposes how immature a person is. Not to mention death threats or wishing a particular person would die. These fall into the category of needing psychological assistance.

Lastly, if I had to compare Yoshinori and Shibafu, the latter is a better artist. Yoshinori does not have the same level of anatomic grasp. As for the designs, I would tend to favor Shibafu as well, given the idea the game was developed to: girls and historical warships to cater to Military Navy otaku in Japan. This particular public can be very frisky with details, and Shibafu is better suited for this.