Talk:Suggestion/@comment-26715360-20160909190539

I'm not sure this should be discussed here since it's such a minor "issue" that affects only a few shipgirls, but here goes nothing.

Back in december, there was an update that added new post-marriage secretary voices for a few shipgirls, namely Italia, Musashi Kai and the Agano-class sisters in their Kai form. The wikia page dedicated to this update ( http://kancolle.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:376288 ) states that the old post-marriage secretary voices of those shipgirls can still be heard as idle voices "under specific conditions".

After this update, I realized that, in addition to her new post-marriage secretary voice, whenever my married Italia was sparkled, her idle voice would always become her old post-marriage secretary voice. Her idle voice would then revert back to her original idle voice whenever she wasn't sparkled anymore. I automatically assumed that the "specific conditions" needed to hear the old post-marriage secretary voices as idle voices for those 6 shipgirls were remodel, marriage and sparkling.

However, I recently saw a user's comment on the Musashi page stating that their Musashi actually used her old post-marriage voice as her idle voice despite not being married (but probably remodeled since she was apparently lvl 43). I decided to test this on my Sakawa Kai and my Noshiro (not in her Kai form), both with and without sparkling. Noshiro's idle voice remained the same even with sparkling. However, with sparkling, Sakawa Kai's idle voice did became her old post-marriage secretary voice despite her not being married. That would mean that the only conditions needed to hear the old post-marriage secretary voices of those 6 shipgirls are remodel and sparkling (again, I'm assuming this based on those few tests, so I might be wrong).

If any of this is indeed true for all those concerned shipgirls, should it be displayed somewhere on their respective wikia pages ? As of now, those pages kind of imply that their old post-marriage secretary voices simply disappear after remodel, and don't indicate that they can still be heard under “specific conditions" (said conditions being remodel + sparkling based on the previous tests). It could be done by adding the old post-marriage secretary line to the idle tab of the quotes section with the extra conditions in parenthesis (which is already being done for shipgirls who have different voices based on whether or not they've been remodeled).