Talk:Suggestion/@comment-25637142-20160724184715/@comment-460323-20160726185413

To be fair, it's precisely that comment of yours that makes me think you're planning to somehow improvise the Talk thing to make it work. I mean, some things just don't need to be tested to know they won't work.

Regarding the TabviewArticleComment, I can't imagine how you'll be able to make it works either. For one, it segregates the comments. While comment segregation is the wet dream of all editors here, people that had completed a map will move on to the next tab and won't be able to offer their advice because, well, they don't even realize someone's asking that. This is further worsen by the fact that comments aren't shown in Wiki Activity.

But let's say you're a dedicated player that wants to offer your assistance to those newbie because you're a great person. Congratulations, now proceed to check every single tab by scrolling up to change tab and then scroll back down to the comment section.

Speaking of scrolling, mein gawd is those comments long. And that's before factoring the inevitability of someone starting an argument over the best setup for a particular map, which will lengthen the page considerably. Perhaps you can cut the number of comments per comment page short, but the more you cut, the lesser is the probability of someone seeing your comment or to get a discussion going before it fades away to the next page and forgotten forever.

Last but not least, there's two comment sections in a page now so have fun scrolling up and down why refreshing the comment :v.

I mean, you guys probably had all this figured out since you're coding it now, but the current sandbox page and your description doesn't really tell much to the public :v.