Talk:General Discussion/@comment-24430017-20140718082900/@comment-90.201.165.136-20140718153057

I'd say ryuusei kai is generally better than the tomonaga type 99s.

The type 99 has 1 AA and that is the real creditable advantage. The ryuusei kai has 2 more torpedo - it is stronger. Accuracy does not affect the air strike (evident from fatigue making no difference) so it is not very meaningful on carriers. ASW is irrelevant as there are better and these would likely be used on CVs and not CVs.