Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26460664-20151025005953/@comment-26154973-20151025025122

Here is a plot (fp, torpedo, fp + torpedo, hp, armor, sorted by fp + torpedo):



Technically Z1/Z3, Mutsiki/Kisaragi, Ushio and Hatsuraru all have Kai Ni, but lower damage output (excluding Hatsushimo and Shigure because of their high luck).

If defensive stats such as armor and HP are not important, then it's settled, she isn't bad at all, and if they are... then she is even better :) Same for ASW (though it's irrelevant, "strong" ASW gives +0-few more damage compared to "weak"). For AA with Akizuki guns her adjusted AA is ~14% less than Fubuki's.