Talk:General Discussion/@comment-203.115.247.114-20140918065213/@comment-24702213-20140918134111

I don't think Hiyou survived with 1 hp, but is sunk. 2 thing to note:

1) Even if Hiyou is at 1 hp, Chiyoda has more hp, so the battle result should result in a A rank

2) @Kiryuu87 did Chiyoda attack at the shelling phrase or is it skipped? If it's skipped then Hiyou is considered sunk. If she did then my first point woul dbe valid and the problem is still there (S rank to A rank, but gotten D rank instead)

The only thing I can think of if either it's a bug or you misremebered it.