Talk:List of light cruisers by upgraded maximum stats/@comment-26139968-20150305161901/@comment-861160-20150307093312

Mathiaszealot:

I realize that the EliteCLT page exists entirely to have a working link from Torpedo Cruiser. The problem is, that isn't the main reason why we have these pages. Their purpose is listing the max stats and comparison between max stats, plus some useful information above/below the table. When a list has three unique ships in it it seems rather silly to have such a page at all, although I do understand why it exists. I also don't oppose putting the link in Template:Shiplist, but I do have other thoughts on that subject which I've explained elsewhere. I'll refrain from dragging it up here.

From Arteria's language in his/her(?) first response in this thread it sounded very much to me like the directive was to stop immediately editing the page and wait for discussion to be carried out first (which, as I stated previously, I think is silly due to the small sample sizes garnered.)  The pace of discussion, if Suggestion is any example, is something on the order of weeks, unless we go with the wiki "consensus" definition. I realize "consensus" on this Wikia is usually just two people agreeing and then nobody else caring enough to stop them, but if that's the working definition we're going to use I don't see the point in having the discussion prior to the edits occurring (given it's something not major). Nobody had even suggested (or carried out) complete reversions on this page prior to that "cease and desist" comment so it sounded more reactionary to me than anything, and if I misinterpreted his/her intentions initially I appologise for that.

I stand by my comments on the whole "Suggestion page simmering process" that I made earlier. While I was blunt, I believe I clearly conveyed my misgivings with the current system without exaggerating.