User blog comment:Homuhomu123/Shelling Accuracy Test Results/@comment-25196231-20150112182021/@comment-25779449-20150113035747

Thanks for the comment. Yes dechi you have a point there. Actually I can't understand why he used Sanshiki and Seiran for the exp't, either. So according to stricter procedure, the test is not 100% convincing for everyone.

However, if we look at it another way, we may find out something. Let's say comparing CA who used 20.3cm with those who are equipped with 15.5cm. Notice that despite their differences in turrets, their extra equipment are exactly the same. (sanshiki + #21 radar). Let's assume these two will give the same effect on any CA listed above, then the rest should be clear.

But that's a good point to mention. I will add this onto the chart.

As for the purpose of this study

III - Night Battle DA Accuracy Bonus by Using 20.3cm (CA.CAV.CLT)
In think the subtitle explained itself. Although I was looking for something else, perhaps something you suggested there, this is however what the exp't gave me.

Addressing the latter two, yeah their equipment are more firmly controlled, but the sample size is really too small to assume anything. I'm not sure if you have seen or performed similar exp'ts with sample size = 100+, but according to my experiences over the exp't I performed, they made me a firm believer in statistical correctness rather than coincidence. Therefore, imho the latter 2 exp't really cannot confirm anything.

Please let me know if I explained myself clearly.