Talk:Akashi's Improvement Arsenal/@comment-24786587-20150601034746/@comment-24786587-20150604095839

first of all, yes I've read Homuhomu123 version as well:

http://kancolle.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:Homuhomu123/Shelling_Accuracy_Test_Results#IV_-_The_.22Fit_Gun_.2B_Overweight.22_Mechanics_on_BB_.28Red_Morale_Test.29

I believe you're talking about Yamato lv140 source #782, it compares Yamato without any gun vs 4x 46cm

from data: accuracy without gun 49.28%, with 4x 46cm 55.04% (all red morale in 1-1-1), I believe this is what you mean, however no vs 41cm comparison and level lv140 is a question if there is any hidden calculation mechanic for overlevelling case.

the original poster comment: 検証してみての感想. あるようにも思える結果がでたが、回数が少ないので単に偏っただけかもしれない. lv140とかなりの高lvなので、そのせいかも. 少なくともペナルティは存在しない と思う. 何にしろ、まだ断定するには早いね、これ.

see 2nd Yamato lv86 tests source #610, this time it compares Yamato lv86 without anygun vs 4x 41cm vs 4x 46cm

from data: accuracy without gun 44.69%, with 4x 41cm 47.46%, with 4x 46cm 40.34% (all red morale in 1-1)

original poster comment: 結論： 46cm適正はないように見える ぺナルティは他の艦種よりかなり軽いようだが、ある.

3rd test on Yamato lv98-99 test source #655/Excel 9, it compares Yamato lv98-99 without anygun vs 4x 46cm only

from data: accuracy without gun 43.2%, with 4x 46cm 39.8%

from all 3 data, I hope you read them separately and not from simplified table by Homuhomu. Unless if I'm missing something, I still can't see why 46cm is the fit gun, again, unless if the term fit gun is different than what Kancolle community have been understood. then there is another thought, fit gun is just fit, no bonus/no penalty, gun underweighting gives accuracy bonus, gun overweight lower accuracy.

(Fit gun only the becomes the matter when it comes to 1- Event,  2-Support expedition. )  <- I'm hoping to keep the topic on fit guns for ships, i.e. : wanting to know which gun fits which ship, not situational things like in your comment.

(Others than that, for ships with lv 93+. There is no need to worry about penalty.) <- yes for sure, that's why I married all my BBs just only for events, I'm afraid to say to non-paying TTK, from my experience, this is really counted as cheating the event, while you can grin during event, you loss the real gameplay experience supposed to be. anyway don't worry, lv99 ships are enough to counter the overweight problem, marrying ships to overlevel only push the limit further.