Talk:Isuzu/@comment-27466725-20180202065057/@comment-28069733-20180202164253

@SunnyTTK

Thanks for the correction. I actually have yet to K2 Tatsuta so I didn't test her myself when she was released.

Just to clarify on something, a comparison comes into play whenever you want to compare ships that all fit inside an use case. Just as an example, comparing the firepower of Tatsuta and Isuzu is a complete moot point because you will not use them for surface combat realistically. If anything, comparing their is the normal thing to do, which indeed shows that Isuzu is better, albeit by 1 point of ASW damage due to him most likely not knowing how ASW damage is calculated. If a comparison is made in order to prove a superiority, the thing to keep in mind is that you also compare the correct things that reflects your arguments.

If he really wants to make the claim that Tatsuta K2 is inferior to Isuzu K2, than he has to prove without doubt that Isuzu is better in any way possible, which he has failed so far. On the other hand, if he just simply made the conclusion that people should K2 Isuzu before Tatsuta and built his arguments around that...

Anyway, I don't know for what reason he was struck before and frankly, I actually don't care. If claims are made, I demand evidence or sound arguments as to why the claim is made. Even if his claim is partially correct, you don't give advice based on dubious/false arguments.